What Metrics Actually Matter? The Overlooked Data You Should Be Tracking to Know if Your Ads Are Working

What Metrics Actually Matter? The Overlooked Data You Should Be Tracking to Know if Your Ads Are Working

What Metrics Actually Matter?

You launched the ad. You spent hours crafting the perfect headline, designing thumb-stopping visuals, and writing copy that you swore would convert. But a few days in, you're staring at your dashboard wondering... is it working? What metrics actually matter?

Most marketers will glance at impressions, click-through rate, and cost per click, then make a snap judgment. But here's the real tea: those metrics only tell part of the story. Worse, they can be wildly misleading if you don't understand what's really happening behind them.

If you're serious about running ads that perform and scale, it's time to go deeper. Let's unpack the underrated metrics you should be tracking and what they actually reveal about your creative and campaign performance.

First, Let's Get the Obvious Stuff Out of the Way

Yes, you should still be looking at the classics: click-through rate (CTR), cost per click (CPC), and return on ad spend (ROAS). They're important, especially when you're making big decisions. But here's where most people stop, and that's exactly where performance starts to plateau.

These surface-level numbers can't tell you why your ad is underperforming. And if you're scaling based on gut feeling or just chasing the cheapest clicks, you're leaving money and insight on the table.

The Real MVP? The Hook Rate

Hook rate is one of the most underrated indicators of ad health, especially in video.

It measures how many viewers watched beyond the first three seconds of your ad. In other words, did your opening line, visual, or movement actually stop the scroll?

In today's feed-heavy attention economy, three seconds is the new gold standard. If people aren't making it past that mark, the rest of your ad doesn't even matter. A low hook rate tells you the creative needs a rework, and fast. A high one? You've captured attention. Now it's time to hold it and convert.

Start measuring the ratio between impressions and 3-second views to gauge your hook rate. It's not always visible in the standard dashboard, but digging into your video view metrics is well worth the effort.

Next Up: Thumb-Stop Ratio

This one's for all the visual-first marketers. The thumb-stop ratio shows how effective your creative is at making people pause mid-scroll. It's especially relevant for image or short-form video ads that rely on a powerful first frame.

Think of it as a gut check: does your ad visually demand attention? Are people actually pausing long enough to register what you're showing them?

Low thumb-stop ratios usually indicate bland or predictable visuals. Strong ones suggest you're sparking curiosity or emotion, two of the most reliable levers for grabbing interest. If you're seeing poor performance, test new thumbnails or start your video with something unexpected. Pattern interrupts work for a reason.

Save and Share Data: The Silent Power Moves

Most marketers ignore this data completely. But saves and shares are subtle signals that your content is resonating deeply, especially in top-of-funnel campaigns. When someone saves your ad, they're saying, "I need to come back to this." When they share it, they're putting their reputation on the line to pass it along. Both are signs that your content hit a nerve in the best way.

Even if these actions don't lead to immediate conversions, they indicate relevance and spark further algorithmic reach. That's free visibility you didn't pay for. Start tracking save and share volume alongside engagement. It's where emotional content and educational value really show their strength.

View-Through Conversions: What Happens After the Scroll

Here's a stat that gets wildly underutilized: view-through conversions. These are people who saw your ad but didn't click right away, only to convert later through another touchpoint like a direct website visit or a branded search.

If you're only tracking click-based conversions, you're missing a big chunk of buyer behavior. Especially in high-ticket or trust-based industries, people don't always convert in the moment. But they do remember.

By understanding your view-through performance, you gain insight into how powerful your brand presence and message actually are, beyond just the click.

Scroll Depth on Your Landing Page

Let's say you're getting good traffic but no conversions. The ad is working, but the landing page might be losing people fast. This is where scroll depth comes in. Scroll depth measures how far users get once they land on your page.

If they bounce before hitting the 25% mark, chances are your headline didn't deliver on the ad's promise, or your design hierarchy needs work. This metric helps you figure out whether you have a conversion problem or a messaging mismatch. Either way, it lets you pivot with precision.

Don't Obsess Over ROAS Alone

ROAS is helpful, but it's a lagging indicator. It tells you what happened, not why it happened or what to do next.

When you zoom in on micro-metrics like hook rate, save/share behavior, and scroll depth, you start making proactive decisions. You optimize smarter. You scale with confidence. And you stop throwing budget at campaigns that look good on paper but fall flat in execution.

Final Thoughts

Running profitable ads isn't just about playing the numbers game. It's about knowing which numbers matter. The marketers who dominate ad performance aren't just looking at CTR and CPC. They're analyzing behavior, decoding patterns, and tracking emotional resonance in the data.

If you're ready to elevate your ad strategy, get beyond the basics and start measuring what truly matters because in today's market, the ad that performs is the one that connects fast, deep, and strategically.

Want help decoding your ad data or writing creative that hooks and converts? Let's break it down and build it better, together.

And don’t forget to…

Grab your FREE CRO checklist